PDF Ebook Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga
From the combo of understanding and activities, somebody can boost their ability and also capability. It will certainly lead them to live as well as function far better. This is why, the students, workers, and even employers should have reading behavior for books. Any kind of publication Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga will certainly offer certain expertise to take all advantages. This is exactly what this Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga tells you. It will certainly include more expertise of you to life and function far better. Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga, Try it as well as confirm it.
Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga
PDF Ebook Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga
Reviewing a book Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga is type of very easy activity to do every single time you want. Also reviewing each time you want, this task will certainly not disturb your other tasks; numerous people typically read the publications Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga when they are having the spare time. What concerning you? What do you do when having the downtime? Don't you invest for pointless points? This is why you have to get guide Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga and also attempt to have reading behavior. Reviewing this publication Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga will certainly not make you ineffective. It will offer a lot more advantages.
Why should be Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga in this website? Get much more revenues as exactly what we have actually told you. You can find the various other eases besides the previous one. Reduce of getting the book Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga as exactly what you really want is additionally supplied. Why? We offer you lots of type of the books that will not make you really feel bored. You can download them in the link that we supply. By downloading Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga, you have actually taken the proper way to select the convenience one, compared with the inconvenience one.
The Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga has the tendency to be great reading book that is understandable. This is why this book Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga becomes a favorite book to read. Why don't you want become one of them? You could appreciate checking out Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga while doing other activities. The visibility of the soft data of this book Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga is type of obtaining encounter easily. It consists of just how you ought to save the book Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga, not in shelves naturally. You could save it in your computer system device as well as device.
By saving Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga in the gizmo, the method you review will additionally be much less complex. Open it and also start reading Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga, basic. This is reason we recommend this Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga in soft documents. It will not disturb your time to get guide. On top of that, the on-line system will likewise reduce you to look Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga it, even without going somewhere. If you have connection net in your office, house, or gadget, you could download Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga it directly. You may not likewise wait to get the book Armored Champion: The Top Tanks Of World War II, By Steven Zaloga to send out by the vendor in various other days.
Armor expert Zaloga enters the battle over the best tanks of World War II with this heavy-caliber blast of a book armed with more than forty years of research.
- Sales Rank: #190129 in Books
- Published on: 2015-05-15
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 10.00" h x .88" w x 8.00" l, .0 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 336 pages
About the Author
Steven Zaloga, an internationally recognized military historian, has written numerous books on the vehicles and campaigns of World War II, including Armored Champion (978-0-8117-1437-2), Armored Thunderbolt (978-0-8117-0424-3), Armored Attack 1944 (978-0-8117-0769-5), Armored Victory 1945 (978-0-8117-0771-8), and The Devil�€™s Garden (978-0-8117-1228-6). He has appeared in programs on PBS and The Military Channel. He lives near Baltimore, Maryland.
Most helpful customer reviews
33 of 34 people found the following review helpful.
World Class Analysis of WWII Tanks
By matt8386
I've been a fan of Steven Zaloga since I first started collecting books back in 1983. I have come to respect his writing and opinion. Armored Champion may be his best yet. It is a superb book for beginners since it addresses so many of the considerations needed when discussing tank vs tank combat. Firepower, protection, mobility, reliability, cost. This is not new, but how this information is presented is top notch as are the printing, paper and illustrations.
Zaloga breaks it down by nation and by time period. He further breaks down analysis by what a tank crew would choose (expensive tank, world beaters) vs what a battlefield commander might choose vs what a nation would choose. Sometimes, those decisions are different and Zaloga outlines why. He supports his decisions with excellent tables, charts, clear B&W photographs and narrative. His choices are sometimes controversial, something he welcomes to promote discussion and differing views. The bibliography and appendix are detailed, helpful and come from many sources, foreign and domestic.
For the more experienced reader, there are still many insights, details and facts to be gathered, the summaries of each nations tank development alone make this a worthwhile purchase. This is not a color photo walk around, it is a highly informative treatise on tank development
The reader's digest view of this book – buy it, it's an excellent collection to the library.
23 of 23 people found the following review helpful.
Not quite up to Zaloga's best writing...but still worth it
By Kindle Customer
Overall, this is a well-researched, enjoyable read. It offers a far more nuanced view of armored warfare then many comparable works on WWII tanks. Zaloga has his usual excellent research and mixes it with informed opinion as well. Perhaps the best parts of the book are various tables and descriptions of studies that I’ve never seen published before, either online or in print. These are sure to provoke spirited debate and discussion. For example, an extensive study by the Russians ultimately rated a Panther Tank as 2.37, with a T-34-85 1.32 with a late model Panzer III rated as the baseline of 1 (Higher is “better”, in this case). Or did you know that a British study gave the Panzer IV a rating of 1.0 rated a 75mm Sherman as a 1.1 (In this case, that means 1.1 75mm Sherman’s to match 1 Panzer IV.), a Cromwell a 1.35 and a 17pdr Sherman a .9 at 1000 yards? Fascinating stuff.
He also adds some new wrinkles to some old debates. For example, he examines the mechanical availability for major types of tanks, but critically he points out that this is not static, the most reliable tank during one part of the war, may not show up so well later on (Although it usually still holds some advantage). For example, the superiority, reliability wise, of the Stug III over all three primary German tanks, (PzIV, Panther and Tiger I) in 1943 is so great that the question is not what tank the German’s should have been making, but why bother making anything other than Stug’s at all. The comparison in 1944 is much closer. Its also noteworthy that the abysmal early reliability of the Panther, while very bad, is at least at times not dramatically worse then the Tiger I (For example PzIV availability in late 1943 was 48%, Panther was 37%, Tiger I was 36%. Yes, that is bad, but they are all pretty bad, which surprised me.)
Which leads to a few complaints. I would appreciate some better context for some of this data. For example, He mentions a British study regarding the IS-2, T-34-85 and Comet. Zaloga cites his source, (Assessment of Forms of Anti-Tank Defense, Effectiveness of British and Russian Tanks. AORG Report No. 11/51 August 1951.) The study concludes the IS-2 is slightly better then the Comet, which is slightly better the the T-34-85, not exactly controversial, but there are no details how its conclusions were derived. I’m confident the actual study is likely as interesting to read as a primer on federal tax law, but part of the reason I enjoy Zaloga’ s writing is that he does give informed opinion. In this case, since the Comet and IS-2 never faced each other, presumably this assessment would come from an analysis of mobility, firepower, protection, accuracy, effectiveness of the fighting compartment etc. Did it include crew survivability? Mechanical reliability and durability? Were they assessing an actual IS-2 Tank etc.? I don’t know, and I would have liked to hear more what he thought about the subject. Since this comparison is similar to what he is doing in this book, it would have been good to get his assessments on the conclusions made.
Likewise, very useful tables are included throughout the book. Readers should be aware that these tables need to be read with the accompanying text. For example when discussing 3rd Army US losses during the Lorraine battles of Sept 1944, at location 3422 of the kindle edition, a table summarizes total US AFV losses as 148, but it only includes tanks, not the M10 and M18 GMC’s. However the accompanying text mentions that total losses for September were 200, including TDs. It also important to look carefully, some of the tables have some formatting issues. For example, a table detailing total German AFV losses in Lorraine for Sept 1944 lists a total of 341 total losses. It also lists US claims, but the formatting is off, it shows US claims as 186 under Panther, 421 under PzKpfw III and 607 under PzKpfw IV, with no claims at all for assault guns/JagPz etc. Obviously the 607 is the total number of claims (186+421), the 186 and 421 might represent claims for Tanks vs Assault guns, or for that matter claims by US tank crews vs US tank destroyers etc., or destroyed vs damaged, but it’s not clear. As the other reviewers have noted, some of the tables are a bit sloppy.
I need to mention that Zaloga thankfully makes it clear when he is dealing with claims versus actual losses, a very helpful detail that is pretty much a prerequisite for any honest assessment of WWII combat vehicles.
Other parts of the book appear rushed. For example the Stug is given a decent amount of coverage, as well as the way it was integrated into the German army, but there is barely a mention of US tank destroyers, which made anywhere from 10% to 20% of US armor strength.
And finally there is really no conclusion, Zaloga reviews the tanks for each period from 1941-1945, but really does not have a concluding chapter where he reviews all the information presented and offers his overall assessment. I understand that a major point of the book is that there was no single best tank of the war, but I’m looking for more of a review of all the information supplied. Again, part of the value of a author like Zaloga is that his opinion is valuable, and I would have like to have heard more of it.
Now that I'm reviewing what I've said, this sounds unduly harsh. Basically the only real issue with the book is that parts of it seemed rushed, the conclusion is really abbreviated, and some of the tables and formatting are sloppy. Critically, this is not a ~$10-15 Osprey book, at the list price of ~$30 I tend to expect a little more of these details to be ironed out. But ultimately I’d say this book, while required reading for AFV fans, is not as good as the superlative Armored Thunderbolt. I gave Thunderbolt 5 stars, so this gets 4.
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful.
An in-depth and thoroughly researched study that showed what went into a "top tank"
By David C. Isby
The concept of identifying the best couple of tanks for each year and campaign of the Second World War, in the author’s capable hands, goes beyond the usual tank-buff arguments and wargamers’ focusing on the importance of those numbers to which they happen to have access. By setting out what are the criteria for combat success in the rapidly changing operational environment that marked the Second World War, the book is an excellent description of what makes a tank effective or a failure, always considered with its larger context in mind.
Solidly researched, the book draws on a broad array of archival and published sources, so much so that it is a valuable first stop for anyone interested in the subject. One hopes the author goes on to do similar overviews – not limited to 1939-45 – first, of the development of tank fire control and armament and, second, of tank battle tactics that can similarly draw on his deep knowledge of the subject.
Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga PDF
Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga EPub
Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga Doc
Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga iBooks
Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga rtf
Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga Mobipocket
Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II, by Steven Zaloga Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar